The Issues class today was one of my favorite days I've ever had in my entire educational career. We talked about class colors, which I previously blogged about. Of course, I am the minority in the belief that we should give up our ties to wearing black as seniors. The majority of people in the school and in the class feel that the class colors are a tradition worth keeping around and look forward to the time they are seniors and get to act crazy at the pep rally/beyond.
I won't get into the specifics of my viewpoints here as I already blogged about that. What I'd like to talk about is my philosophy on group persuasion. Although my opinion was the minority's, I was able persuade group members of the majority or undecided members to see and be more open to my viewpoint. Psychologists call this "minority influence" which they say will only be effective if that group is unwavering in their convictions and do not give in or conform to the majority ways.
Everything about being a minority goes against what we want to feel as teenagers; you do not fit in with the others, you are disliked for not conforming, and you are not loved. It is hard to be the one who stands up and says, "Stop! I disagree with what you're doing". This is hard at any age but the fear is especially amplified in high school. However, it is so important that you learn now how to not give into social conformity if the majority belief isn't something that you believe in. Standing up for yourself is a muscle, and, like any other muscle, you need to use it to make it grow stronger. Practice standing up for yourself everyday and eventually it will be a reflex.
Why practice standing up for your beliefs? The answer is in every history textbook; the people we remember and honor at the head of every movement are people who said "enough" to the majority. Without those people, there would be so much more injustice in our society.
Sunday, September 30, 2012
Thursday, September 20, 2012
Class Warfare
I was so happy when the school announced that it would finally be getting rid of the stupid practice of class colors. I have been against class colors since I was a freshman and even voiced that opinion to my principal but at the time, she "disagreed that class colors incite discrimination". Of course it does! What's a more obvious way to judge someone superficially than to look at them and see that they've painted their faces red or are completely decked out in black clothing? Class colors, especially for the senior class instill deep biases pro-ingroup and anti-outgroup. Being completely dressed in black and surrounded by your peers creates a sense of anonymity which only leads to poorer decision making skills. I remember what it felt like to be a freshman at the 2009 pep rally. The seniors looked moronic in their frenzy. I watched them as if I were watching National Geographic document the congregation of wild apes. I wasn't particularly harassed but I saw people that were. Is it really worth it? Do we want to continue this cycle of "since I had to go through it when I was a freshman I am going to make the freshman feel how I felt and worse"? It's just so... barbaric! If you didn't like taking it as a freshman, why would you want to dish it as a senior? The most annoying part of it all is that seniors automatically think that because we're all wearing the same colors and against the same people that we have more in common with each other than we do with the other classes. It's simply not true. The people that you will see around you are the same people that used to make fun of your acne in middle school or started that rumor about you that made you want to stay home from school. There is no real bond we share in being seniors besides the fake one that school colors give us. I like some sophomores better than I like some seniors, sue me. I don't think it's fun to generalize an entire group of people, the freshmen, and discriminate against them for being in that group. Before you put on you entirely black outfit this upcoming Friday, please, look at yourself in the mirror and ask yourself, "Why?"
Colleges Under "FIRE"
FIRE is an organization that strives to protect the individual rights of speech, religion, liberty, and the sanctity of conscience of students attending higher education. They have a whole database where you can look up your college and see if your school is listed as a school that limits the students individual liberties. It all sounds very great that they are protecting the rights of those who are not protected by the "violations" but here's my question; what does FIRE suppose we do instead of using speech codes and restrictions to make the educational environment more tolerant? There is no denying that something needs to be done about the extremely offensive harassment and hazing that occurs in colleges across the country. I don't mean to suggest that this is what FIRE is saying, but if FIRE wants to argue that all speech should be protected in education, is it ok for teachers to exclude all minorities from their classroom? Is it alright for white fraternity members to dress up in KKK costumes and blackface (read previous post about this below)? It is okay to physically harass another student at the university because they are gay and your religion "condones" (don't get me started about that) gays? In that case, is your freedom of religion protected over the other persons personal freedoms? I get what FIRE is saying and I would agree with them more if they gave a good alternative to completely getting rid of the speech codes at all. I am not necessarily for or against the speech codes as I would never say or do something to harm another student based on their race, religion, or any other point of discrimination. Because I am compassionate person, I don't feel the need to put others down and I try to be as conscious of other peoples beliefs as possible. In a way, I have already implemented my own "speech code" and therefore don't feel restricted by a college speech code. The way I learned my speech code was by following someone else's code and adding in by own research to make it more specific. Maybe the best way to become more compassionate beings is by implementing speech codes. I don't disagree with you, FIRE, I just don't know if someone's personal liberties to make completely vulgar and racist remarks outweighs the other persons rights to be protected from that language.
On a side note, none of the small liberal arts colleges I am applying to showed up on the FIRE database. Ah, the quaintness of a small school...
Tackling Racism: Harder Now than Before?
Back in the 1800's, white men would put black make up on their face and mock Black people by imitating the stereotypes surrounding them. The white audiences loved the vulgar humor and probably didn't think much about what they were seeing and doing. Clearly these barbaric and pathetic practices by those white people are completely racist and show a deep disconnect between white people and their sensitivity. The blackface shows stopped being so popular in the 1960's after the Civil Rights Act, or did they?
Today, racist beliefs are transmitted through the media and pop culture 24/7. Whether we realize it or not, we all internalize those ideas but it doesn't make you racist to have internalized them. Looking back at history and coming to terms with the fact that we live in a de-facto seggregated society gives you clarity and awareness about racism in America. Although we like to believe that America isn't racist anymore because we have an African American president, it's simply not true. We are in a state of self denial about how racist we really are making it, in a way, a harder subject to deal with than it was in the 1960s when racism was publically expressed and therefore more tangible. I would've really hoped that white people got over the degrading and flat out wrongness of blackface shows, yet clearly we haven't learned our lesson. Fraternities across the country, the very large Beta Theta Pi and Delta Sigma Phi included, throw so called "ghetto parties" in which a bunch of white people get together and pretend that they're "thugs, gangstas, hustlas, and pimps" by painting their faces black depicting the African American stereotypes surrounding those characters. Photos have emerged of white frat members in KKK costumes hanging blackfaced frat members at these parties. Since when is lynching a funny subject? I am absolutely revolted by these ignorant actions. Do 18-22 year old university students really need to be reminded of the golden rule we learned way back in pre-school? Some of those frat members are Jewish. What if instead of blackface the christian frat members showed up as Hitler, a nazi, and a prosthetic-nosed Jew being executed by a firing squad to a "Holocaust" themed party? Some of the frat members are christian. What if Jewish members decided to throw an "Old Testament Party" and all dressed as Romans and crucified a fake Jesus? I bet some of those boys would be offended by that. The blackface ghetto parties are no different from the ideas behind these hypothetical parties. We've all been the target of steretypes, dehumanization, and have horrific histories of being persecuted for things as superficial as the way our noses look, how big our lips are, and how firmly we believe in one or multiple gods. These white frats are making the detrimental mistake of assuming its ok to make fun of Black people. It's not, you are no better than anyone else in this country. At one point or another in history, you would've been at the butt of that "joke" too, so learn how to be a decent human being and not even go there. I don't know if it was the University's fault for not setting high enough standards of tolerance on campus, the parent's fault for not teaching those boys the significant damage of racist behavior, or the boys themselves for acting out of ignorance. Then again, maybe it's our society's fault for not properly teaching us our own histories and reinforcing racist beliefs without ever admitting to doing it...
Today, racist beliefs are transmitted through the media and pop culture 24/7. Whether we realize it or not, we all internalize those ideas but it doesn't make you racist to have internalized them. Looking back at history and coming to terms with the fact that we live in a de-facto seggregated society gives you clarity and awareness about racism in America. Although we like to believe that America isn't racist anymore because we have an African American president, it's simply not true. We are in a state of self denial about how racist we really are making it, in a way, a harder subject to deal with than it was in the 1960s when racism was publically expressed and therefore more tangible. I would've really hoped that white people got over the degrading and flat out wrongness of blackface shows, yet clearly we haven't learned our lesson. Fraternities across the country, the very large Beta Theta Pi and Delta Sigma Phi included, throw so called "ghetto parties" in which a bunch of white people get together and pretend that they're "thugs, gangstas, hustlas, and pimps" by painting their faces black depicting the African American stereotypes surrounding those characters. Photos have emerged of white frat members in KKK costumes hanging blackfaced frat members at these parties. Since when is lynching a funny subject? I am absolutely revolted by these ignorant actions. Do 18-22 year old university students really need to be reminded of the golden rule we learned way back in pre-school? Some of those frat members are Jewish. What if instead of blackface the christian frat members showed up as Hitler, a nazi, and a prosthetic-nosed Jew being executed by a firing squad to a "Holocaust" themed party? Some of the frat members are christian. What if Jewish members decided to throw an "Old Testament Party" and all dressed as Romans and crucified a fake Jesus? I bet some of those boys would be offended by that. The blackface ghetto parties are no different from the ideas behind these hypothetical parties. We've all been the target of steretypes, dehumanization, and have horrific histories of being persecuted for things as superficial as the way our noses look, how big our lips are, and how firmly we believe in one or multiple gods. These white frats are making the detrimental mistake of assuming its ok to make fun of Black people. It's not, you are no better than anyone else in this country. At one point or another in history, you would've been at the butt of that "joke" too, so learn how to be a decent human being and not even go there. I don't know if it was the University's fault for not setting high enough standards of tolerance on campus, the parent's fault for not teaching those boys the significant damage of racist behavior, or the boys themselves for acting out of ignorance. Then again, maybe it's our society's fault for not properly teaching us our own histories and reinforcing racist beliefs without ever admitting to doing it...
Thursday, September 13, 2012
Hiroshima
In class today, we began talking about the damage that 9/11 has caused our country. I brought up the theory that Ward Churchill had gotten in so much trouble for teaching in his college class; did America do something to deserve the terrorist attacks? Ward Churchill said that the bombings of Hiroshima could be seen as an example of something America has done that could have caused it's image to be painted so ugly. My class didn't like the fact that I was suggesting that Hiroshima wasn't justified and it ended up turning into a very heated class debate; almost everybody against me.
Look, I've had my fair share of being the odd man out in discussions. I think the stronger you stay to your true convictions versus giving into normative social influences makes you a stronger debater but I'm not going to lie, it really sucked to be singled out like that. I looked up more information later on about a legitimate justification for the bombings of Hiroshima because I wanted to fact check the other students. To the attack that states "the bombing of Hiroshima saved thousands of other lives"- this is a false statement that president Truman's cabinet put together to justify the use of the atomic bomb. Japan had sent multiple attempts to create peace treaties with the US in Spring of 1945. Months before the end of the war, Japans leaders declared that "defeat was eminent". Every one of the peace treaties were overturned by the United States and as history goes, they dropped the atomic bomb on August 6th. To the attack that "Hiroshima was a military base and thus needed to be destroyed" or "Hiroshima needed to be destroyed because they were manufacturing weapons": this is a flat out lie. Almost all of the victims of Hiroshima were civilians and the United States Strategic Bombing Survey stated in it's official report: "Hiroshima and Nagasaki were chosen as targets because of their concentration of activities and population."(http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v16/v16n3p-4_Weber.html). On top of that, all manufacturing factories had been put out of business in early April due to and oil shortage. To make it all worse, there was mass food shortages in Nagasaki and Hiroshima and almost all of the population were malnourished (these are not the "emperor crazy, weapon dwelling, American flag burning" enemies that so many people imagined; they were weak, tired, and sickly people who, for the most part, were in favor of ending the war).
These were just a few main points that were argued in todays discussion that I thought deserved a little editing. As I made clear during class today, I was not arguing that Hiroshima shouldn't have happened. I was merely trying to show that there are parallels between the horrors of 9/11 and of Hiroshima. 3,000 were killed in September and an estimated 140,000 died in August, 1945. I am not saying that one is worse than the other and I do understand the points that everyone was trying to make in class today. I get it, I really do. I just also believe that there is a sense of American narcissism that when we are attacked it's because other people are crazy and that when we attack other people, we are justified. Just think about it a bit. Post your comments if you'd like, but be nice.
-Donna
Wednesday, September 12, 2012
That's My Kind of (First) Lady
I made it a goal of mine that I would try my hardest to remain unbiased when comparing Ann Romney's speech to Michelle Obama's at last weeks conventions. Of course, I will have my biases about policies and about their husbands but I wanted to listen from a more neutral perspective; I decided to listen to them based on how genuine they sounded. What I heard from Ann Romney speech was that she loves her husband, her family, and that she has had to overcome very difficult personal battles to get where she is today. On a very surface level, I liked her speech. You could tell that there was an unwavering allegiance to her husband which made the duo more appealing. On a deeper level, I found that I didn't entirely believe that what she was saying was authentic. She sounded stiff when talking about when she and Mitt were newlywed. Yes, the line about eating tuna fish salads in the basement was kind of funny and relatable but her tone wasn't. Hey, I think it's totally fine if you're not a funny kind of lady, I have no problem with that. Just don't pretend that you are funny because it comes off awkward. If I had to pick between going with Ann Romney on a weekend hiking trip which are usually filled with tons of laughter, practical jokes, and keeping each other good company or going to a dinner fundraiser, I would pick the second one. I wish that the Romney campaign wouldn't pressure her to act a certain way because I don't think that she is. By the end of her speech, I felt a sense of emptiness that I couldn't explain until the following week.
Dear Michelle Obama, will your husbands affordable care act cover the surgery I'll need to put my brain back together after your speech blew it to pieces? All joking aside, what a home run speech! I was standing up, applauding my kitchen television (I wouldn't have been surprised if my neighbors called a mental ward to come pick me up as I must have looked bonkers) for the last 5 minutes of her speech. She really nailed everything. Her delivery was quick and witty, her pacing flowed beautifully, her tone crescendoed at every appropriate time, and, best of all, she never sounded rehearsed. Her passion for making the country more fit and love for her family made her so appealing to me. Michelle Obama is the kind of woman that you want to be the leader of your brownies troop, or head of the PTO so that she could chaperone all your field trips. She's so appealing to me and I think it's because of her bona fide sense of self. I wish that I had tried harder to become friends with the Obama girls while they were still in Chicago because I'm sure Michelle would be that cool kind of mom that would order us pizza or let us watch scary movies at sleepovers. I will always regret not knowing if Michelle would've let us sleep in till 12:00 in the afternoon or if she would've woken us up so that we could eat the homemade pancakes she prepared...
Just for your information, I would really, really, really like to stress that I am not saying that I would vote for Obama just because I thought his wife would make good pancakes... This piece is purely for the readers enjoyment and I encourage you to comment back and tell me your opinions on the wives speeches!
Dear Michelle Obama, will your husbands affordable care act cover the surgery I'll need to put my brain back together after your speech blew it to pieces? All joking aside, what a home run speech! I was standing up, applauding my kitchen television (I wouldn't have been surprised if my neighbors called a mental ward to come pick me up as I must have looked bonkers) for the last 5 minutes of her speech. She really nailed everything. Her delivery was quick and witty, her pacing flowed beautifully, her tone crescendoed at every appropriate time, and, best of all, she never sounded rehearsed. Her passion for making the country more fit and love for her family made her so appealing to me. Michelle Obama is the kind of woman that you want to be the leader of your brownies troop, or head of the PTO so that she could chaperone all your field trips. She's so appealing to me and I think it's because of her bona fide sense of self. I wish that I had tried harder to become friends with the Obama girls while they were still in Chicago because I'm sure Michelle would be that cool kind of mom that would order us pizza or let us watch scary movies at sleepovers. I will always regret not knowing if Michelle would've let us sleep in till 12:00 in the afternoon or if she would've woken us up so that we could eat the homemade pancakes she prepared...
Just for your information, I would really, really, really like to stress that I am not saying that I would vote for Obama just because I thought his wife would make good pancakes... This piece is purely for the readers enjoyment and I encourage you to comment back and tell me your opinions on the wives speeches!
Sunday, September 2, 2012
Is Mitt Using the President's Race to Win the Presidential Race?
If you've been tracking the election online and/or on the news, which I hope you are, you have probably heard of Mitt's completely false allegations against our President's "work for welfare" policy. The lie-vertisment claims that the Obama administration has adopted a "a plan to gut the welfare reform by dropping work requirements". The ad continues to claim that "you wouldn't have to work and you wouldn't have to train for a job". FactCheck.org, a nonpartisan, nonprofit, monitor of the factual accuracy of what our politicians say, reports that Romney's attacks against Obama's welfare policies are, in fact, false. Under our presidents actual welfare policy, the states are allowed to reform their "work for welfare" requirements and no part of the 1996 Welfare law will be gutted. Mitt- what's with the lies? Why make up that Obama wants to cut the "work for welfare" requirements?
It is clear that these false allegations are pulling at the tassels of a very dark and low political stratedgey; using racism to get white people to vote for you. The most common misconception about welfare is the idea of the Welfare Queen. Does anyone remember when Ronald Reagan talked about the welfare queen? He described her driving her pink cadillac to cash in her welfare checks and using food stamps to buy her groceries (aka her liquor). This tactic was aimed at white voters who believed that the African American race were known to be freeloading, lazy, and uncivilized. All of these stereotypes are obviously untrue but yet politicians still try to provoke white people to believe the stereotypes. So why is Mitt telling voters that Obama is eliminating the work for pay requirements? Mitt is tapping into Reagan's welfare queen tactic almost 2 decades since its birth. Getting white voters to believe that "since Obama is black, he must only care about black people" is the feeling I get from this message. It's like saying that if you vote for Obama you may as well hand your hard earned income over to the welfare system where the queen is waiting to cash it in for a new diamond ring. The welfare queen is so degrading to African Americans and people who need welfare assistance (who, in fact, are primarily white) but I also find it degrading to white people that Mitt Romney's team would try to pull something so foul in this election. Clearly, the Romney team has no intentions of apologizing for their lies and its negative impact on increasing racist beliefs. It just goes to show how pathetic and impotent they really feel compared to Barack Obama when they need to resort to using something as superficial as his race against him...
It is clear that these false allegations are pulling at the tassels of a very dark and low political stratedgey; using racism to get white people to vote for you. The most common misconception about welfare is the idea of the Welfare Queen. Does anyone remember when Ronald Reagan talked about the welfare queen? He described her driving her pink cadillac to cash in her welfare checks and using food stamps to buy her groceries (aka her liquor). This tactic was aimed at white voters who believed that the African American race were known to be freeloading, lazy, and uncivilized. All of these stereotypes are obviously untrue but yet politicians still try to provoke white people to believe the stereotypes. So why is Mitt telling voters that Obama is eliminating the work for pay requirements? Mitt is tapping into Reagan's welfare queen tactic almost 2 decades since its birth. Getting white voters to believe that "since Obama is black, he must only care about black people" is the feeling I get from this message. It's like saying that if you vote for Obama you may as well hand your hard earned income over to the welfare system where the queen is waiting to cash it in for a new diamond ring. The welfare queen is so degrading to African Americans and people who need welfare assistance (who, in fact, are primarily white) but I also find it degrading to white people that Mitt Romney's team would try to pull something so foul in this election. Clearly, the Romney team has no intentions of apologizing for their lies and its negative impact on increasing racist beliefs. It just goes to show how pathetic and impotent they really feel compared to Barack Obama when they need to resort to using something as superficial as his race against him...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)