Monday, January 14, 2013

My Two Moms. Religion and Homosexuality

At the height of Zach's media attention, news anchors and interviewers wanted to pick his brain on everything from being a boy scout to his philosophy of religion in relationship to homosexuality. Zach talks in the book about how if someone drinks a can of diet coke or buys a playboy it's not immoral because they are not affecting anyone else's lives by doing so. If someone smokes a cigarette in a room by themselves, it might be unhealthy, but it's not immoral because they are not affecting anyone else with secondhand smoke. However if that person were to light up in a room full of toddlers, that is immoral because not they are hurting someone else. There is nothing inherently immoral about eating pork but, to an observant Muslim, it is an affront to god. Zach says, "To conservative Christians sleeping with someone of the same sex is committing a sin. In some denominations, working on sabbath is considered immoral. Tattoos are thought to be by many to be unclean due to religious beliefs. But tattoos are increasingly popular, Walmart is open 24/7, and the U.S Supreme Court has ruled that antisodomy laws are unconstitutional and a violation of privacy."

Getting the idea? Zach is saying that there are a lot of things that religions can deem immoral but that doesn't mean that the law sees those actions in the same way. His philosophy is that you should be able to do what you want so long as it doesn't harm other people. The right that allows Christians to be able to speak against homosexuality in their churches is the same law that protects a homosexuals right to be who they are; we have a right to speak our minds and pursue our happiness'. It's interesting to me that America still hasn't really grasped the idea that it is not inherently immoral if it does not damage another being in a rational way. I remember when my dad came home from his first trip to the United Arab Emirates, I asked him what the best part was. He said he saw these two business men in an argument and they were holding their hands behind their backs. He thought they looked pretty silly and was waiting to see if one of them would actually punch the other. But they never did; the heat died down, they shook hands, and parted. When my dad asked his friend why they had their hands behind their backs, his friend said that it was because it is illegal for them to fight. Fighting is causing another person harm and to them, that would be criminal. It's very interesting and different from American culture. If you were to adapt this philosophy in America, what would that mean for gay marriage? Since there is absolutely no rational evidence on the face of this earth that Two consenting people of the same sex being married affects anyone else, it should be legal. 

P.S (I italicized "consenting people" for those weirdos out there who like comparing gay marriage to inter-species marriage, a.k.a beastiality. Key words: consenting, people.)

My Two Moms. Boy Scouts

Zach Wahls refers to his eagle scout status a lot in the book. He says that being a boy scout taught him everything he needed to know about how to respond to the world's judgments. The boy scout motto is "Be Prepared" and Zach lives by that expression in every way. However, the book was published right before all of the controversy revolving around the Boy Scouts of America's anti-gay policies. The BSA fired a lesbian scout leader because of her sexual orientation which caused an uproar from the other parents of the children in the troop and nationwide. It was strange timing that this would all unfold only a few months after Zach released his book. I can only imagine how devastating it was for Zach to hear how the club that he loved and believed in him would betray his family like that. It take so many hours of community service and complete dedication to become an eagle scout, but he did it. Then the leaders of his club openly discriminate against people like his parents. I'm sorry, I can't think of an blog appropriate word for those "leaders". 

Zach is such an interesting guy- as soon as he heard about the controversy, he started a campaign to get the BSA to revoke their anti-gay policy. Just a year before he had delivered a speech to the Iowa House that received massive media attention, then he releases his best selling book which then lead him to be one of the leading speakers in the battle for equality in the BSA. Seriously? Does he ever stop? I don't understand how he has time for anything else besides being an activist. Well, it was just last week that the gay 18-year-old Ryan Andersen's eagle scout application was approved unanimously by the Mt. Diablo-Silverado Council. However, a few days later 11 councilman of the BSA overturned the acceptance letter. Zach Wahls asked "Why not put out a call and make it a democratic process? Why have a secretive committee make the decision?" in an interview with ABC news. Good questions. I enjoyed doing this background research because I was wondering if Zach would've had something to say about the BSA after praising them so much in his book. I would've been satisfied if he had just made a statement on his blog or something, but no, this is the Zach Wahls we're talking about. He had to not only do interviews with as many newspapers as possible and give as many public speeches humanly possible but he had to collect 275,000 signatures for a petition. He's truly a marvel to me, I have no idea how he has enough energy to fight as hard as he does. Though he doesn't like to admit it in his book, he's really gifted. 

Sunday, January 13, 2013

My Two Moms. "Coming Out"

This book has caused me to think about the concept of coming out a lot lately. Even though Zach is not gay himself, he often talks about how he had to come out as the son of lesbian parents often when he was a kid. His parents sat him down and had a conversation with him that most kids in America don't have to have, telling him how people may view their family as unusual or unconventional because he had two moms. He often says that "I don't have to tell you that growing up in small town in Iowa is no Greenwich Village." In other words, it wasn't easy to have lesbian parents in an area that is not as accepting of non-comformity. Coming out is a reoccurring theme in the book because Zach is confronted with many questions when his friends come over for the first time or when the parents of his classmates see his two moms at PTO meetings.

I think that Zach makes a point to talk about how tedious coming out can be. It's something that a lot of people don't have to think about, but to the average gay or lesbian it's a looming thought. I have always felt very alone in my belief that having the preverbal "coming out" speech is somewhat outdated. I think that Zach feels this way too, as he talks about how it seems like such a big deal to come out when you are young but that as he got he saw how it really shouldn't be that big a deal. I have nothing against the people who decide to have some sort of announcement when they come out but I will say that I personally wouldn't feel true to myself if I did something like that. My question has always been why come out as gay if straight people don't have to come out as straight? Why put labels on ourselves? I would like for people to not be able to label me; that is my freedom. For some people, their freedom is to be able to shout that they're gay to people they know and don't know alike. That's fine. But for me, it's to never label myself, because words really have meaning. I feel sexuality is too fluid to be summed up in a phrase. Human beings are too complex to be summed up like that. When we give each other names like gay, lesbian, bisexual, genderqueer, or whatever else, aren't we all just trying to figure out a way to make something unconventional fit neatly into the puzzle of society? Isn't that exactly why people have such a difficult time accepting LGBTs, because they were 'unknown' and 'undefined'? Sometimes I think that we feel the need to define ourselves to help society define us. I don't just mean this for gays and lesbians though, I mean this for all people. The best way to have society not define you is to not tell them; they can guess, but they'll never really know. I exclude close family and friends from society, of course, because when you're close to someone they will see beyond the surface.

Now, to reiterate, I am not saying that coming out is a bad thing to do. Everyone handles it differently. These are just some questions that reading this book has brought to my mind.

Monday, January 7, 2013

My Two Moms- The Issue is that There Are No Issues

I've been reading the book My Two Moms: Lessons of Love, Strength, and What Makes a Family by Zach Wahls for a few weeks now. Some of you might know Wahls- he delivered a speech regarding Resolution 6, a proposed amendment to Iowa's constitution that would define marriage as between a man and woman only, to the Iowa House of Representatives. If you haven't heard of him, check it out now. The video you see of his speech was uploaded to Youtube by Iowan House Democrats, unbeknownst to him. The video blew up all over the internet and on the news. Zach later appeared on the Ellen DeGeneres show and a year later published his first book; My Two Moms. My mom actually bought it for me, I think she saw it at Barnes and Noble and thought it would be a nice addition to my collection of LGBT-related books and films. It's pretty delightful so far. The stories of how his mom, Terry, (a.k.a "Tall Mom"), would test his memory of the boy scout's slogan, motto, and oath at the dinner table was very relatable and touching. I picked this book for my Issues in Modern American Society class because of this controversial question; can gay parent's actually raise children ("well")? I think it's a silly question, but to some people it's a legitimate concern. However, this book is filled with relatively little controversy that I sometimes feel it's not provocative enough for my Issues class. But isn't that the beauty of the book? This guy had a pretty happy and completely normal upbringing outside of the fact that he has two moms. The strength of this book is that it irrationalizes all the fears of those who doubt the strength of familal-love, reguardless of genders and sexual orientations. I imagine gay-parent-skeptics pick this book up thinking it will be packed with sob stories and chapters called "where's my daddy?" but what they find out is that having gay parents didn't make this child's life any harder than a child with hetero parents. There are no stories of molestation, abuse, overbearing or neglectful parents here. Just two, loving women who are raising two, nice kids. That's all. :)

Woman to Woman

I recently read an article  called Guns and the Decline of Young Men published on The Stone which is editorial branch of the New York Times. The article was written by Christy Wampole, an assistant professor of French at Princeton University. She discussed her theory behind why she thinks there is such a rise in the numbers of young white men who are committing these organized crimes such as the ones at the Sandy Hook Elementary School. She believes that the reason for these crimes are not because of the guns or because of our violent media and socitey but rather because young white men feel they do not have a purpose. She thinks that since we've proved to them that minorities and women are just as smart as them that they don't feel like their special anymore. Since we've shown white men that a woman is capable of raising a child without a man, now white men feel useless. Christy wants us, I'm assuming she's referring to women and minorities, to take pity for the white man whose power is in decline. I find Christy's theory completely superficial and degrading to women and minorities who are still not equal to the white man despite all the many triumphs we've had. She uses the phrase that "white men are on the decline" but is she forgetting how there was a point in this country when white men didn't allow women or miorities to vote? Are women supposed to give up their rights to divorce and rights to work for equal pay just so some mentally ill white men feel powerful and will stop shooting American children? It's propostruous. I don't know what world she is living in but in the real world, women and minorities still make up the majority of America's poverty, colored faces still fill the majority of our prisons and women still make 30% less than what men make for the same work. If the problem here is truly about race and it's shifting powers, which I'm not sure it is at all, then the issue isn't that our society has completely deprived white men of all their previous opportunity; the problem is that we never taught them how to share. Power, money, and opportunity does not belong to a select group of people; it belongs to us all. So lets not get it twisted- white, heterosexual men still have a lot going for them. Although, I (am proud to) admit that women, minorities, and queers are making headway, lets not be scared into giving up what we've fought so hard to gain.